Another chance to object. Another chance to hit that yellow button!
DEADLINE for objections: December 9th 2026!
It's objection time again folks. This time, though it's being managed by Pembrokeshire County Council, this is a great opportunity to submit an objection that will reach Welsh Government.
It's also addressed to Pembs Council Planning Committee. Why? Well, they're now no longer going to be ultimately deciding DARC (since it was called in!)—but they will soon be giving their opinion, and that still plays a part.
Let's make them stand up and listen right now. Go ahead and smash the yellow button below to load up our pre-written email in your client!
Don't forget to put your name and address at the bottom of the email!
Done? Awesome. You've helped Pembrokeshire take a huge and important step towards fighting DARC!
ANY PROBLEMS WITH THE BUTTON?
No problem! The button can sometimes be broken in various ways for some.
If that happens, do this: start a new email, give it an appropriate title (say 'Objection against DARC'), copy and paste the below email addresses (just as they are, with commas) into your email's CC box, and then copy and paste the whole long email text below that into your email's body. Make sure you put your name and address at the bottom of the email. Then hit send. Simples!
Dear Pembrokeshire County Council Planning Support Team, Planning Committee Councillors, and the Planning Minister (copied for reference),
I write to you today, as an individual, in formal objection to the DARC radar proposal at Cawdor Barracks, Brawdy, Pembrokeshire, SA62 6NN, PCC reference 25/1101/PA. I write, however, also to appeal to the good conscience of the Councillors of the Planning Committee, whose upcoming opportunity to issue an opinion on the proposal, though not finally decisive in and of itself, is of profound importance to the St Davids peninsula community, and represents a judgement that will have historical significance.
The proposal, on both the grounds of visual impact and tourism harm but also the concerning path being taken globally by the radar array’s US architects, has attracted an extraordinary level of opposition, from the public, from local businesses, and from planning and statutory authorities.
The opposition reflects the widespread understanding that despite the site being located on the border of PCC’s geography, a full 17 of the 33 studied representative viewpoints are in the National Park, and a further 4 on its border. The majority of the proposal’s visual impact, which is acknowledged by the ZTV and the planning application generally to adversely undermine a wide and open remote landscape of breathtaking beauty, would be felt by that National Park, by the tourism visitors that are the heart of the local area’s economy, and by permanent residents. Such is the extent of this predicted impact that it cannot be understated that PCNPA, as the very planning authority most directly and seriously adversely impacted, has objected to it formally.
It is, in my view as in the view of many, fair that the planning authority most harmed by a proposal acknowledged to be in violation of Local Development Planning policy by all sides should be given special consideration under the circumstances, and supported by PCC, along with its residents, in its rejection of a proposal that it judges would unacceptably harm a landscape of immense value to the county, and harm tourism in one of Wales’s most important visitor economies.
As is established by now, two prior PCC studies (2015 and 2021) into the suitability of wind turbines on Cawdor Barracks define small wind turbines as being of 20m in height, a height comparable to DARC’s 27 antennas of 21.5m height, all of which would be at equal altitude in the landscape. These same studies not only recommended against development of such turbines on adverse visual impact grounds: they would find that only a very small number (3 at most) of small turbines might have been acceptable, assuming, even then, they were not densely clustered. DARC, however, would involve 27 unmitigably densely clustered structures, on average 1178% greater in lateral volume each versus a turbine of the same height. It is clear that no such development as DARC should ever be considered on visual grounds.
Far from comprising a visual and socioeconomic impact that contravenes planning policy, however, it is the strategic and military implications of the proposal that have drawn such surprising and widespread opposition throughout the community, and, naturally, much further afield.
DARC, at first a little-understood proposition that was shrouded in opacity, has become understood, through the dedicated research of locals working nearly full-time for three years to oppose the development, to show extensive documentary evidence of providing the targeting element of offensive space weapons capabilities, at a time in which an ever more congested space commons means that a nation striking even one satellite is, as shown by the seriousness of preceding diplomatic incidents, a risk that is liable to cause catastrophic orbital debris chains (the Kessler syndrome), capable of eliminating entire parts of the civilian satellite infrastructure upon which much of society depends.
Extensive analysis, provided in a military and strategic objection document developed by PARC of nearly 90,000 words of evidenced research, finds expert space traffic and debris management opinion indicating that over the course of decades of awareness of space debris, the US military, DARC’s primary proposer and confirmed funder, has shown almost no true motivation for the claimed aims of space traffic management or debris cataloguing, goals already supported extensively by a vast network of ground-based and space-based sensors.
Deeper research has revealed that in fact, DARC is more relevantly intended to be involved in the US Golden Dome (or ‘Iron Dome for America’), an extraordinarily internationally controversial proposal, pursued without success or support for decades by prior US administrations, to fill a previously peaceful space commons with some one hundred thousand missile-armed US satellites. Despite Golden Dome’s allusions to Israel’s missile system, a remarkable scientific and political consensus across the US, embodied notably in the American Physical Society which includes advisors to both the US President and the CIA, has found not only that such a proposal would defy the laws of both physics and fiscal possibility, but would be perceived as a dangerously inflammatory strategic concept by increasingly dominant rival military powers, who have made many public statements to this effect. Notable amongst them is one editorial-level opinion in a Chinese Communist Party-controlled media outlet describing the very planning proposal being considered by this Committee as a ‘significant escalation’ within the context of global security and safety.
There is no question that a proposal that risks being involved in such a controversial strategic pathway involves serious implications for the safety of the St Davids peninsula. As those closely following the Iran conflict will be aware and as has been evidenced by objectors, the majority of US radar array sites in the Gulf have been targeted and destroyed, most of them as a matter of the very first priority by the IRGC, and these facts have been a materially significant factor for the breakdown of US missile defence and security guarantees for both the Middle East and further afield. Bases struck have already indeed included the UK’s own Diego Garcia space radar base, whose deep-space radar mirrors that of a DARC site almost exactly.
While a last remaining counter might be that DARC would contribute to space traffic management (STM), it is perhaps in this area that the proposed development fails most. The suggestion by the applicant that DARC could singularly comprise a global space traffic management system is, as has been noted by many, an absurd proposal. The reason for this is that as in the case of air traffic management, it is only extensive international cooperation, the comprehensive sharing of ephemeris (trajectory data) and defined cross-border working agreements, that can enable traffic management and keep satellite infrastructures safe. Yet quite simply, it is clearly the case that three western countries acting alone (AUKUS), without sharing comprehensive and unclassified data with and taking such data from other spacefaring powers (including and not limited to China, Russia and India), with no agreed rules of the road in space, cannot coordinate all nations’ satellite operators’ movements without their consent, and most certainly cannot unilaterally run a space traffic management system.
More than this though, DARC has clearly not been shown to make a net contribution to a highly complex picture of space traffic and orbital debris management. Factors such as the documented failure by the US military space catalogues to which DARC’s data would primarily go to declassify that NOFORN-classified data; urgent problems surrounding the proliferation of overwhelming low-probability collision warnings that it is suggested further sensors (such as DARC) would only be further exacerbating; a failure by the US to invest in the more-needed data processing compute required to deal with what is already an excess of data, generated by multiple space situational awareness infrastructures of equal function to DARC such as GEODSS, GBOSS, SBSS, Sapphire, GeOST, SensorSat, the Space Fence, Lincoln Space Surveillance Complex, and Globus II; and the general inability of any current satellites to perform evasive manoeuvres against attacks (or many against debris), or international law to compel any operator to do this, altogether suggest the motivations behind DARC are far from productive, far more aligned with offensive military capabilities, and motivated far more by business enterprise than a genuine engagement with orbital management problems that have been ignored by the US for decades.
For information concerning any specific point raised, the Committee is invited to peruse and search the military and strategic segment of PARC’s objection, available at parcagainstdarc.com/parc-planning-objection. All statements in this objection are substantiated by over 750 referenced sources given in across the documents available, which comprise nearly 180,000 words of content.
It is, in light of these factors and so many others, abundantly clear that the PCC Officer’s report, which bases the weight of its planning balance almost entirely on national security considerations, has fundamentally failed to engage with the complexity, extensive strategic issues raised, and vast amounts of evidence presented in objections. The report, while acknowledging extensive visual impact harm and that ‘a causal link to an effect on the tourism industry cannot be discounted,’ reaches national security conclusions outside of its scope of professional judgement, and offers flawed factual judgments that could otherwise have been corrected by an engagement with objectors. As a result of these failures, a formal complaint against the Authority is being progressed.
A clear remaining material consideration is that of jobs, and in that regard, the picture is bleak. Beyond that the applicant itself admits even the widely-challenged promise of jobs would be of ‘low numbers’ and ‘not significant’ in PCC’s context, DARC and the current 14th Signal Regiment of 400-600 staff clearly cannot both simultaneously remain on site.
Yet as articulated well by former MP Stephen Crabb, the on-off question of whether the Regiment will ultimately stay or leave saw a March 2013 announcement that the Barracks would close, then the announcement of a closure but not before 2018, then a 2015 decision for the Regiment to stay, then an announcement of another closure in 2024. The MOD clearly has not historically, and cannot, provide certainty to the premise that the counterfactual of DARC would ever truly be an evacuation of the Regiment. DARC, however, is the only certainly sure way that the Regiment is very much guaranteed to leave: and with it, what is ultimately a net loss of hundreds of jobs, with predictable economic effects for the locality, beyond even those acknowledged upon tourism. Such an outcome has been resisted consistently by local businesses, most of which have supported PARC’s campaign, and many of whose logos have been present on PARC’s website since the day of the campaign’s launch.
Where there would often be two sides to any significant public debate in a community, what is extraordinary about DARC is that according to all recorded attempts to measure public opinion undertaken by the applicant and PCC, there has been nothing less than essentially unanimous opposition to the proposal. An unprecedented 1,126 objections against the proposal (with only one in favour) have been lodged by the public; the applicant’s pre-application statutory consultation resulted in 401 confirmed objections, with all other applicant-summarised responses also being objections; PCNPA and Welsh Government body NRW have formally objected; the public petition against the proposal stands at nearly 20,000 signatures; and 39 cross-party MSs and MPs have signed formal parliamentary motions opposing it. More could not have been asked of tireless local campaigners in working, without pay and for the good of their community, to examine the proposal’s impacts in ways the applicant has shirked its responsibility to do in one botched consultation after another, and show public feeling.
A further key consideration is the lack of sufficient examination of site alternatives. While DARC is generally opposed in principle by most, and is not a proposal that would be wished upon any community, it is clear that the MOD’s argument that one existing site with light and portable security requirements must be the only place DARC could be sited, in a UK that the MOD acknowledges is filled with countless disused airfields and over a thousand according to even the most basic database research, is not valid. That the Australian DARC site is pictured as having no security perimeter fencing at all relatively undermines the argument that it would not be entirely plausible for DARC to be sited in plenty of other sites, other than the UK’s only coastal National Park.
Some local residents have already relocated as a result of the proposal, and many are bound to do the same. While matters such as the loss of the soul and character of an area and the loss of family wealth in property value can be seen as trivial matters in planning processes, they are far from trivial for families whose lives would be upturned by the proposal, whose homes would become a distant memory, and whose proud and culturally celebrated landscape would be given to industrial proliferation of a controversial nature, starting today perhaps with just DARC, but no doubt expanding to irrevocably lose that character of the area, as has happened with other US-led military project bases in the UK.
The Planning Committee has a once-in-a-lifetime opportunity to make what would be a popular decision, but yet also, according to every known piece of evidence, a decision that is the right one under known planning law, and the scope of relevant consideration for the Local Authority whose first charge is to consider and protect Pembrokeshire. I urge you, on this count, to stand up for your county, make that decision which is popular but also right, and recommend against the DARC proposal, protecting Pembrokeshire and its key National Park for generations to come.
NB: inasmuch as PEDW and/or other relevant planning Authorities are minded to consider further objection materials beyond the word length of this present written representation (which is under 3,000 words in length, as per PEDW guidance), I wish to state that the objection documents available at parcagainstdarc.com/parc-planning-objection are hereby submitted by myself formally as an additional part of this objection, and I invite the relevant Authorities to consider them, as appropriate, in addition to this text.
Yours faithfully,
[IMPORTANT: insert your NAME AND ADDRESS HERE!]
Think of anyone else who might share your opposition to DARC? Let them know about this objection page!
Feel free to pop this message right into a post on a platform like Facebook, and let friends and family know about the opportunity to object...
I just voiced my opposition to the DARC radar array to Welsh Government in the BIG new consultation.
It was so easy!
Looking for a super handy template email with all the objections written up ready? Check out...
www.parcagainstdarc.com/takeaction
Thanks so much!
Looking for an image to help your post along? Feel free to use this one (click or tap to open in a new window)...
Aaaand...
That's it. Fantastic work, and thanks so much!
Did you know you guys seriously sent an absolutely bonkers 1,079 planning objections through this page last time?
Y'all are a force of pure chaotic good, and we are here for it.
Catch you on the next one...
If you can somehow contain your excitement until then!
Thanks so much for all the actions you're taking to help protect the St Davids peninsula. Let's make DARC history!